Wednesday, 6 August 2014

Today's prize for shoddy, ignorant music journalism goes to...






... Philip Oltermann of The Guardian. (It is actually a report dated 31 July, but since we are dealing with journalism, what's a fact or two between friends?) A Twitter friend brought this to my attention, and it is quite staggering, even by the normal standards, clearly written by someone who knows nothing about Wagner, Bayreuth, music, nor indeed, it would seem, anything about anything else.













'Long considered the embodiment of German high culture...'
By whom, and in what sense? I cannot recall having heard anyone speak of it in such terms, insofar as those terms might be considered meaningful.

'Bayreuth's opera festival is becoming more notorious for its scandals than its music...'
'Becoming'? Do you know anything about the history of the Festival? Have you perhaps heard of the Third Reich, of Winifred Wagner, or indeed of a host of controversial stagings, at the very least from Wieland Wagner onwards?

'Director Frank Castorf's radically deconstructed six-hour production of Wagner's Ring of the Nibelung...'
Six-hour production?! As another Twitter friend commented, that is 'radically deconstructed' indeed. It certainly took longer when I was there last week.

'Director Frank Castorf's radically deconstructed six-hour production of Wagner's Ring of the Nibelung was met with boos and jeers when it premiered at Bayreuth last year...'
So now you are talking about something that happened last year? In what sense is this conceivably a news item?

'Castorf, an experimental east German director drafted in after the film directors Lars von Trier and Wim Wenders declined invitations...'
Well, only in the sense that he was 'drafted in' after the death of Winifred Wagner or indeed after the death of Richard Wagner. Lars von Trier was due to direct the previous 'Ring' at Bayreuth.


That is quite enough for now. I really cannot be bothered with the rest: poorly digested, if at all, from other reports... (There is, though, serious competition from an error-laden, almost comically reactionary piece - 'horrible modern-dress concepts that have become the bane of every opera lover's existence' etc. - in The Daily Telegraph on the Munich Opera Festival, should you really wish to seek it out.)


Alternatively, you might spend your time more wisely listening to this:




3 comments:

Zwölftöner said...

'Horrible modern-dress concepts' is a great letdown; Rupert should have dropped it after the reassuring undertone of his 'don't worry, this resort does do English food' aside about the Brits in Munich, and then it would have been an object lesson in appearing to say something nice about the Germans while dog-whistling to your readership that, no, you haven't stopped being an obnoxious tool.

David Rosenbaum said...

He forgot to mention that Wagner was Hitler's favorite composer. :)

David said...

Michael Church is on holiday (or was, leaving the Indie to ignore his admirable stand-in Alexandra Coghlan's review of the essential Glyndebourne Traviata for days...)