Sunday, 6 June 2010

Carmen, Royal Opera, 5 June 2010

Royal Opera House, Covent Garden

Moralés – Dawid Kimberg
Micaëla – Maija Kovalevska
Don José – Bryan Hymel
Zuniga – Nicolas Courjal
Carmen – Christine Rice
Frasquita – Elena Xanthoudakis
Mercédés – Paula Murrihy
Lillas Pastia – Caroline Lena Olsson
Escamillo – Aris Argiris
Le Dancaïre – Adrian Clarke
Le Remendado – Harry Nicoll
Guide – Anthony de Baeck

Francesca Zambello (director)
Duncan Macfarland (revival director)
Tanya McCallin (designs)
Paule Constable (lighting)
Arthur Pita (choreography)
Mike Loades (fight director)
Natalie Dakin (revival fight director)

Actors, Dancers
Members of Trinity Boys’ Choir and Trinity School, Croydon (director: David Swinson)
Members of Tiffin Girls’ School Choir (choirmaster: Simon Ferris)
Royal Opera Chorus and extra chorus (chorus director: Renato Balsadonna)
Orchestra of the Royal Opera House

I wish I could dislike Francesca Zambello's production of Carmen as much in practice as I do in theory. Zambello’s West-End spectacular approach relies upon a naturalism that might even give the stage directors of Shaftesbury Avenue pause for thought. It in no way seems to have moved on from what I saw at the Deutsche Oper, Berlin last year – except that was a 1979 production, hurriedly revived when a new director fell ill. There are manifold irritations: the ‘picturesque’ urchins, the horse and donkey, and worst of all, the grotesque Madonna wheeled on for a priest to bless Escamillo and Carmen before the bull-fight. (Zambello seems to have a thing about Madonna figures, as witnessed by her Covent Garden Don Giovanni, in which the religious imagery had more of a rightful place, though it was a far worse production.) And yet, in a way, it all works. There are no revelations; there is no discernible concept at work. One is nevertheless grateful for the lack of perversity and for relative lack of impediments to the characters’ expressing themselves. Intimacy is lost – and that is a serious thing for Carmen, an opéra comique, not a grand opera. If Zambello were a composer, she would surely be Meyerbeer. But Meyerbeer had a certain sense of theatre and there are times when one might prefer to listen to the best of Les Huguenots to certain other, far-from-neglected swathes of the operatic repertoire. Duncan Macfarland certainly does his best as revival director to make it all work and to ensure as much interaction between the characters as the too-grand staging will permit. It will probably look impressive in a straightforward sort of way on the big screen.

Vocally, we had a mixed bag. Bryan Hymel struggled for much of the time as Don José. At his most cruelly exposed during the arias, he picked up somewhat for the final scene. When I saw this production before, the role was taken by Jonas Kaufmann: a more than usually odious comparison. Likewise for Ildebrando D’Arcangelo’s smouldering, chocolate-toned Escamillo and the present run’s Aris Argiris. Argiris can be forgiven, though, for lacking the sheer charisma of such an operatic star. All in all, he showed considerable promise, though he seemed to tire in the fourth act. Nicolas Courjal, however, made a more virile impression as the lieutenant, Zuniga, than either of the two principal men. Christine Rice is a versatile artist, with repertoire ranging – at least – from Monteverdi to Birtwistle. She is not, however, the first person I would have thought of as a Carmen. That said, she did a good job of confounding expectations through her innate musical intelligence and a stage presence of not inconsiderable sensuality. Her French compared favourably with that of most of her colleagues (a major bugbear throughout). Maija Kovalevska made Micaëla as interesting a character as I have experienced in the theatre, presenting a figure of greater allure than the typical pallid angel we and, to some extent, the score expect. This was an impressive house debut by any standards. There was, moreover, much to be impressed with in the smaller roles. Elena Xanthoudakis’s Frasquita and Paula Murrihy’s Mercédès sounded a true gypsy – or rather, Bizet’s fantasy-gypsy – presence, whilst a subtly modulated Moralès from Dawid Kimberg made one wish that the character might return. The choral singing was excellent: full marks not only to Renato Balsadonna and his Royal Opera chorus (augmented) but to the children’s choirs, from whom one could hear every word. Dancing and choreography were of an impeccably high standard too.

However, the true star of the evening was without a shadow of a doubt the conductor, Constantinos Carydis, marking another Royal Opera debut. He presented Bizet’s score with fire, colour, grace, precision, dramatic flow, and true structural coherence. The darkness that lies beneath the surface was powerfully conveyed, not least the ‘real story’, belying Carmen’s words, of which he spoke to me in an interview a week previously. Here we could feel, quite frighteningly, the nature of her real feelings for Don José – at least those of who bothered to listen and to turn off our mobile telephones. There was not an ounce of sentimentality, just as it should be in this work of realism. The omnipotence and omnipresence of Fate could be heard from the pit, without any descent into melodrama. In this, the contribution of the Orchestra of the Royal Opera House was, of course, crucial. Every section was excellent: one was reminded once again that this is an orchestra, which, on top form as here, can rival any. I hope that we shall hear more of Carydis in London and at Covent Garden. Many good things have been said about his Gluck and his Mozart: an opportunity to judge for ourselves would be most welcome.


Anonymous said...

I am afraid we were not at the same performance!!!
I disagree in everything that you wrote except of the comment about Carydis. he was really excellent!!
BUT! What you wrote about the singers is absolutely 100% wrong!!!
I am really sorry to read such a thing from your Blog which I thought is a very good one...
Christine Rice was fantastic! Great Vocal Stamina, presence and Charisma!!! Bryan Hymel maybe a little bit not Spinto enough for Jose but he sung throughout the hole Performance with great intensity! Aris Argiris was a very attractive a vocally fantastic Escamillo!!! At last someone with a big voice that doesn't have troubles with "Votre Toast.."!
I saw my self D'Arcangelo and I must say your Charismatic Opera Star was fighting vocally pretty much with this Role.Kovalevska was really very good!!! Very good profile of the role and beautiful singing!!For all the rest I agree with you in most of the points. But please, be more attending and careful on how you criticising such great performances!!! I don't think it shows how really great was Carmen yesterday!
All the best!!!

EC said...

Without wanting to re-write Mark's review, I agree with him more than the comment from Anonymous. I thought Rice did a fine job, but I wouldn't describe her Carmen as '"fantastic". I too heard Kaufmann sing this last, which is a little unfair on Hymel. Hymel also does a good job - I (entirely subjectively) just don't find his tenor particularly appealing in sound. And it goes on... but the point is that this is musically good Carmen. It would be wrong to say it was great.

Anonymous said...

Everybody has the right to write his opinion and to say how it feels for him a performance.
I have a big problem though with the criteria for doing that. And I think Mark's criteria they don't really have to do with knowledge on operatic vocal projection,of knowledge of the music of the opera that he is writing his review on so on...
For example is not really serious to write about chocolate-toned Escamillo and lacking of charisma comparing with an "Operatic Star".
For me it is a big mistake to compare singers of this or that... then if we do that we should put on the side all the new opera stars because most of them have at least the half of the qualities of - for example - Cappuccilli, Milnes , Freni, Baltsa, Corelli...etc. I think Bryan is a maybe still young for doing Jose but is a very promising singer and for sure did very well at this performance and kept the standards of Covent Garden. The same I cab say for Christine Rice that for ma opinion was better than Antonacci.Kovalevska was vocally impressive but I didn't hear in her voice and saw in her interpretation 17 years young girl! Why then Jose says in the opera that she is 17 if she sound and plays like 35? Loud is not always beautiful!Aris Argiris is maybe the only baritone that i heard until now that he takes serious the word "Chanson of toreador" and sings it like on!!! We are get used to hear Escamillo's shouting this beautiful aria from the beginning till the end and the only think that we see is only red faces from pushing!!! I was very happy to hear a very confident singing with a lot of colours an his singing. If that is not a charisma...!!!It was a very beautiful evening and I really think that what Mark wrote has some very positive points on it (Zuniga, Frasquita, Mercedes and maestro Carydis) but the comments about the principals are not showing me someone that sees objectively and with deep knowledge of the opera music!Thank you and I hope/wish that my opinion will put Mark at least to think about some things.. Best!

Anonymous said...

Just saw that, because of very quick typing, I did some mistakes! Sorry for that!!
For example i meant "... like one!" and not " on".etc.

Henry Holland said...

the comments about the principals are not showing me someone that sees objectively and with deep knowledge of the opera music!

It's obvious English isn't your first language, but you might want to look up "irony" because you chide Mr. Berry for not being objective while all you do is offer YOUR opinion, which is totally subjective.

Jonathan Stafford said...

This production popped my opera cherry, and I loved it. The staging was fantastic and a spectacle, the singers (both main and choir) were all superb (I was a tenor in a choir so I like to think I know a good voice when I hear one) and I found myself crying my eyes out when Don Jose sang of his love for an all too demanding Carmen. It was a classy night out and I for one recommend going.